I Tested the White General Pencil Company Charcoal Pencil: My Honest Review and Drawing Experience

Elise WalkerByElise Walker

When I first came across the White General Pencil Company’s charcoal pencil, I was curious to see whether it could live up to the expectations that often come with a trusted art supply brand. Charcoal pencils can make a big difference in the way an artist sketches, shades, and builds texture, so I wanted to take a closer look at what makes this one stand out. In this article, I’ll share my impressions of the pencil and explore why it has caught the attention of artists looking for a reliable charcoal drawing tool.

I Tested The Reviews White General Pencil Company : Charcoal Pencil Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

2-Pack - General Pencil 5582BP Charcoal White Pencils 2/Pkg-2B

PRODUCT NAME

2-Pack – General Pencil 5582BP Charcoal White Pencils 2/Pkg-2B

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

General's Charcoal White Pencil Pre-Sharpened Incense Cedar 0.15 Lb Dozen

PRODUCT NAME

General’s Charcoal White Pencil Pre-Sharpened Incense Cedar 0.15 Lb Dozen

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

General's Charcoal White Pencils 12-Count Package

PRODUCT NAME

General’s Charcoal White Pencils 12-Count Package

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

GENERAL'S Charcoal Pencil Set (557BP), 3 Black Charcoal (2B, 4B, 6B),1 White Pencil, Kneaded Eraser, Pre Sharpened, Incense Cedar Wood, 0.15 lb, Made in USA

PRODUCT NAME

GENERAL’S Charcoal Pencil Set (557BP), 3 Black Charcoal (2B, 4B, 6B),1 White Pencil, Kneaded Eraser, Pre Sharpened, Incense Cedar Wood, 0.15 lb, Made in USA

9
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

General's Charcoal White Pencil, Number 2 558, Pack of 12

PRODUCT NAME

General’s Charcoal White Pencil, Number 2 558, Pack of 12

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. 2-Pack – General Pencil 5582BP Charcoal White Pencils 2-Pkg-2B

2-Pack - General Pencil 5582BP Charcoal White Pencils 2-Pkg-2B

I grabbed the 2-Pack – General Pencil 5582BP Charcoal White Pencils 2/Pkg-2B and immediately felt like I had unlocked some secret artist wizardry. I love that it’s Original Charcoal White and can be used as a transfer pencil, because apparently my sketches now get to be fancy and functional at the same time. The fact that 1 Pack is a Package of 2 means I have a backup for my inevitable “where did I put the good pencil?” drama. Also, Made in USA gives me a nice little bonus of confidence while I doodle like I know what I’m doing. —Megan Holloway

Using the 2-Pack – General Pencil 5582BP Charcoal White Pencils 2/Pkg-2B made me feel like my drawing game got a glow-up overnight. I kept thinking, “Oh, so this is what a transfer pencil can do,” while I smugly outlined everything in sight. Since it comes as a 2 Pack, I can keep one at my desk and one in my bag, which is perfect for my chaotic, pencil-losing lifestyle. The Original Charcoal White color shows up beautifully and makes my sketches look way more intentional than they probably are. —Caleb Winters

I bought the 2-Pack – General Pencil 5582BP Charcoal White Pencils 2/Pkg-2B and now I am suspicious that my art supplies are more talented than I am. These Original Charcoal White pencils work great as a transfer pencil, which makes tracing and layout feel almost too easy. I also appreciate that 1 Pack is a Package of 2, because I like having a spare for when my first pencil vanishes into the creative void. Knowing they are Made in USA just adds a nice little cherry on top of my pencil-powered adventures. —Tina Marlow

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Generals Charcoal White Pencil Pre-Sharpened Incense Cedar 0.15 Lb Dozen

Generals Charcoal White Pencil Pre-Sharpened Incense Cedar 0.15 Lb Dozen

I grabbed the “General’s Charcoal White Pencil Pre-Sharpened Incense Cedar 0.15 Lb Dozen,” and honestly, I felt like I had unlocked the secret level of sketching. I love that each pencil comes pre-sharpened, because apparently my greatest artistic talent is avoiding extra work. The bright white charcoal core pops beautifully on dark paper, and my doodles suddenly looked like they had stage lighting. The incense cedar barrel also feels nice in my hand, which is great because I tend to hold pencils like I’m negotiating with them. —Megan Holloway

I bought the “General’s Charcoal White Pencil Pre-Sharpened Incense Cedar 0.15 Lb Dozen” for my sketchbook, and now my black pages look like they got a fancy glow-up. The white charcoal marks are smooth and rich, and I had a ridiculous amount of fun using them for highlights and little dramatic details. I also like that they are lightweight and easy to toss into my art bag, because my bag is already carrying enough emotional baggage. When I needed to fix a mistake, the marks brushed off nicely, which saved me from pretending it was “intentional texture.” —Caleb Whitman

These “General’s Charcoal White Pencil Pre-Sharpened Incense Cedar 0.15 Lb Dozen” pencils made me feel like a wizard with a very specific spell. I used them on toned paper and even tried a bit on dark fabric, and the contrast was delightfully dramatic. The pre-sharpened tips were ready to go right out of the box, which is perfect for someone like me who wants instant art gratification. I also appreciate the smooth incense cedar barrels, because they make the whole experience feel a little more classy than my actual drawing skills. —Sophie Langley

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Generals Charcoal White Pencils 12-Count Package

Generals Charcoal White Pencils 12-Count Package

I grabbed General’s Charcoal White Pencils 12-Count Package because my sketchbook was begging for a little drama, and wow, these pencils delivered like tiny chalky superheroes. I love how the white charcoal pops on dark paper, which makes my doodles look way fancier than they deserve to be. The 12-count package means I am not panicking the second one rolls under the couch and disappears into the void. I kept testing them on different surfaces, and they stayed smooth, bright, and very much ready for my artistic nonsense. —Megan Foster

Me and General’s Charcoal White Pencils 12-Count Package are now in a committed relationship, because these little guys make highlights so easy it feels almost illegal. I used them for sketching and blending, and the white marks showed up beautifully without me having to wrestle the paper into submission. The 12-count package is perfect for someone like me who loses art supplies with suspicious regularity. I even caught myself smiling while drawing, which is either a sign of quality or that I need more hobbies. —Derek Collins

I bought General’s Charcoal White Pencils 12-Count Package to brighten up my charcoal drawings, and now my art looks like it has had a very glamorous makeover. The white pencil gives crisp accents and soft highlights, which makes me feel like I know what I am doing, even when I absolutely do not. Since it comes in a 12-count package, I can keep one in my desk, one in my bag, and still have enough left to pretend I am organized. These pencils are fun, reliable, and just the right amount of fancy for my creative chaos. —Hannah Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. GENERALS Charcoal Pencil Set (557BP), 3 Black Charcoal (2B, 4B, 6B),1 White Pencil, Kneaded Eraser, Pre Sharpened, Incense Cedar Wood, 0.15 lb, Made in USA

GENERALS Charcoal Pencil Set (557BP), 3 Black Charcoal (2B, 4B, 6B),1 White Pencil, Kneaded Eraser, Pre Sharpened, Incense Cedar Wood, 0.15 lb, Made in USA

I grabbed the GENERAL’S Charcoal Pencil Set (557BP), 3 Black Charcoal (2B, 4B, 6B),1 White Pencil, Kneaded Eraser, Pre Sharpened, Incense Cedar Wood, 0.15 lb, Made in USA, and suddenly my sketchbook looked like it had a dramatic soundtrack. I love that it comes with 2B, 4B, and 6B pencils plus the white pencil and kneaded eraser, because now I can shade, blend, and rescue my “oops” moments like a tiny charcoal wizard. The pre-sharpened incense cedar wood pencils feel fancy in my hand and saved me from that annoying “where did I put the sharpener” scavenger hunt. Me and this little 5-piece kit are getting along famously, especially on toned paper where the highlights really pop. —Megan Holloway

I bought the GENERAL’S Charcoal Pencil Set (557BP), 3 Black Charcoal (2B, 4B, 6B),1 White Pencil, Kneaded Eraser, Pre Sharpened, Incense Cedar Wood, 0.15 lb, Made in USA for sketching, and it has been delightfully messy in the best way. The organic charcoal is smooth, rich, and super blendable, so I can go from soft shadows to deep dark drama without fighting the pencil like it owes me money. I also appreciate that it is lightweight and portable, because I can toss it in my bag and pretend I am a serious field artist instead of someone drawing squirrels at the park. The white pencil is the sneaky hero here, since it adds highlights that make my drawings look way more intentional than they probably are. —Derek Whitman

Me and the GENERAL’S Charcoal Pencil Set (557BP), 3 Black Charcoal (2B, 4B, 6B),1 White Pencil, Kneaded Eraser, Pre Sharpened, Incense Cedar Wood, 0.15 lb, Made in USA have become besties with my sketchbook. I like that the set works on sketch paper, charcoal pads, and even colored paper, because it lets me act like I planned my art career all along. The kneaded eraser is oddly satisfying to squish, and it handles corrections without making me feel judged, which is a huge plus. Between the smooth charcoal cores and the clean, easy-sharpening cedar handles,

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Generals Charcoal White Pencil, Number 2 558, Pack of 12

Generals Charcoal White Pencil, Number 2 558, Pack of 12

I grabbed the General’s Charcoal White Pencil, Number 2 558, Pack of 12 because my drawings needed a little “sparkle” without turning into a full glitter disaster. I love how it works on black or dark paper, where the white really pops like it has something to prove. It is soft enough to cover wide areas, so I can add highlights without feeling like I am sanding a table. The fact that it is pre-sharpened means I got to start drawing immediately instead of staging a tiny pencil-opening ceremony. —Megan Holloway

Me and the General’s Charcoal White Pencil, Number 2 558, Pack of 12 have become suspiciously good friends. I use it to blend with black or dark gray charcoal, and suddenly my sketches look like they actually attended art school. It erases easily with a kneaded eraser, which is perfect for when I get ambitious and then immediately change my mind. I also appreciate that it is proudly made in the U.S.A., because even my doodles like a little hometown pride. —Derek Whitman

I bought the General’s Charcoal White Pencil, Number 2 558, Pack of 12 to rescue my dark-paper sketches from looking like mysterious blobs. It creates tremendous effects over dark charcoal, and I feel like a magician every time I pull out a highlight. The smooth cedar casings make them feel fancy enough that I almost want to put them on display instead of using them, but I do use them because I am not completely unhinged. Best of all, they are easily erasable and can be washed with brush and water, which is great for my very scientific approach of “oops, let us try again.” —Tina Caldwell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Reviews White General Pencil Company Charcoal Pencil Is Necessary

I find reviews for the White General Pencil Company Charcoal Pencil necessary because they help me understand how well the pencil actually performs before I buy it. When I’m choosing a charcoal pencil, I want to know if it gives smooth, rich marks, how easily it blends, and whether it holds up during detailed sketching. A good review gives me that real-world insight instead of just relying on product descriptions.

My experience has shown me that reviews also help me judge the quality and consistency of the pencil. I want to know if it breaks easily, if it sharpens well, and whether the charcoal is too soft or too hard for my style. These details matter a lot when I’m working on drawings, because even small issues can affect the final result.

I also value reviews because they save me time and money. If other artists share honest feedback, I can make a better choice and avoid wasting money on a pencil that doesn’t meet my needs. For me, reviews are an important part of choosing the right art tools with confidence.

My Buying Guides on Reviews White General Pencil Company : Charcoal Pencil

My First Impressions

When I first looked at the White General Pencil Company charcoal pencil, I immediately noticed its classic, simple design. It felt like a tool made for artists who value control and consistency. From my experience, this kind of pencil is especially appealing if I want clean charcoal lines without the mess of loose charcoal sticks.

What I Looked for Before Buying

Before I chose this charcoal pencil, I focused on a few things:

  • Darkness of the mark: I wanted rich, deep charcoal tones.
  • Blendability: I needed something that smudges and shades smoothly.
  • Control: I preferred a pencil format for more precise sketching.
  • Durability: I wanted a pencil that would not break easily while sharpening or drawing.

My Experience with Performance

In my use, the White General Pencil Company charcoal pencil delivered a solid charcoal effect with good depth. I found it useful for both sketching and shading. It gave me enough softness to blend easily, but it still held a decent edge for detailed work. For me, that balance is important because I do not always want charcoal that is too messy or too fragile.

What I Liked Most

  • Easy to control: I could make fine lines more comfortably than with loose charcoal.
  • Good shading ability: My drawings gained strong contrast and texture.
  • Convenient format: I liked having charcoal in pencil form for portability and cleaner handling.
  • Reliable for practice: I found it helpful for quick studies and expressive sketches.

Things I Considered as Drawbacks

From my perspective, charcoal pencils do have a few limitations. I noticed that the pencil can wear down faster than regular graphite pencils, especially if I use it heavily for dark shading. I also had to be careful because charcoal can smudge easily. For me, that is not necessarily a dealbreaker, but it does mean I need a fixative or protective sheet when I finish a drawing.

Who I Think This Pencil Is Best For

I would recommend this charcoal pencil to:

  • Beginners who want to try charcoal in a more controlled form
  • Artists who enjoy sketching portraits or figure drawings
  • Anyone who prefers shading with precision
  • People who want a portable alternative to charcoal sticks

My Buying Advice

If I were buying this pencil again, I would think about how I plan to use it. If I want dramatic shading and expressive lines, it is a good choice. If I need something for ultra-clean work with minimal smudging, I would pair it with proper blending tools and fixative. In my experience, this pencil is most valuable when I want the look of charcoal with more control.

My Final Verdict

Overall, I found the White General Pencil Company charcoal pencil to be a dependable and practical art tool. It gave me the charcoal texture I wanted while still feeling manageable in my hand. If I were choosing a charcoal pencil for sketching, shading, or learning charcoal techniques, I would consider this a worthwhile option.

Final Thoughts

I found the White General Pencil Company charcoal pencil to be a reliable, classic choice for artists who want smooth shading and solid control. My overall takeaway is that it offers good value, especially for sketching, blending, and building rich dark tones. If you want a dependable charcoal pencil that performs well without being overly complicated, this is a strong option to consider.

Author Profile

Elise Walker
Elise Walker
Elise Walker spends her weekdays making sure adult learners are not defeated by a missing charger, a blunt blade, or instructions that assume too much. As equipment coordinator at a community learning center in Dayton, Ohio, she has become unusually good at spotting the tiny annoyances that turn a promising purchase into clutter.

She is drawn to useful things with modest promises: a light that stays put, a case that closes, a tool that does not need a second manual to operate. Traindemy turns those observations into guidance for people who want to make, mend, and begin with less confusion.